{
    "products": [
        {
            "slug": "karakeep",
            "name": "Karakeep",
            "kind": "web",
            "website": "https://karakeep.app/",
            "page": "https://listme.name/software/karakeep",
            "tagline": "Open-source bookmark and read-later app with AI tagging and search",
            "summary": "Karakeep is an open-source, self-hostable app for saving links, notes and images. It tags items with AI, fetches titles and archives full pages, and offers apps for iOS and Android plus browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox.",
            "platforms": [
                "web",
                "ios",
                "android",
                "browser-extension",
                "self-hosted"
            ],
            "pricing": "open-source",
            "price_note": "Free to self-host; Pro cloud plan is $4 per month or $40 per year",
            "free_to_use": true,
            "open_source": true,
            "license": "AGPL-3.0",
            "source": "https://github.com/karakeep-app/karakeep",
            "strengths": [
                "Open source under AGPL-3.0",
                "Semantic search and OCR for images",
                "Apps for iOS and Android"
            ],
            "limits": [
                "AI tagging is central, which some users may not want",
                "Self-hosting needs a server"
            ],
            "checked": "2026-10-10",
            "connected_to_publisher": false,
            "overview": "Karakeep saves links, notes, images and PDFs, and it fetches titles and descriptions automatically. Full-text search covers everything saved, and semantic search finds items by meaning. OCR makes text in images and screenshots searchable.\n\nSelf-hosting is free under AGPL-3.0. The project also offers a free plan and a Pro plan at $4 per month or $40 per year for hosted use, which includes AI tagging and 50GB of storage. AI tagging is a core part of the product, which some users may not want. It works well as both a read-later list and a bookmark archive."
        },
        {
            "slug": "shaarli",
            "name": "Shaarli",
            "kind": "web",
            "website": "https://shaarli.readthedocs.io/",
            "page": "https://listme.name/software/shaarli",
            "tagline": "Minimal self-hosted link list that stores data in files",
            "summary": "Shaarli is a minimalist, self-hosted bookmarking service that its project describes as database-free. It is free software released under the zlib/libpng license and is maintained by a community of contributors.",
            "developer": "Sébastien Sauvage",
            "platforms": [
                "web",
                "self-hosted"
            ],
            "pricing": "open-source",
            "price_note": "Free software to host yourself under the zlib/libpng license",
            "free_to_use": true,
            "open_source": true,
            "license": "zlib/libpng",
            "source": "https://github.com/shaarli/Shaarli",
            "strengths": [
                "Stores data in plain files without a database",
                "Free software under zlib/libpng",
                "Minimal and self-hosted"
            ],
            "limits": [
                "Needs a web server and setup",
                "Fewer features than hosted or newer tools"
            ],
            "checked": "2026-10-10",
            "connected_to_publisher": false,
            "overview": "Shaarli stores links without a database, so the whole collection lives in files on the user's server. The project describes itself as a personal, minimalist and fast bookmarking service. Its copyright notices date from 2011 and name Sébastien Sauvage and the Shaarli Community.\n\nShaarli suits people who want a minimal self-hosted link list and are comfortable with server setup. Its documentation describes it as free software, and no paid tier is listed. Karakeep and Linkwarden suit people who want full-page archives and AI tagging, while Shaarli keeps the feature set small."
        }
    ],
    "differences": [
        "Only Karakeep runs on iOS.",
        "Only Karakeep runs on Android."
    ],
    "shared_rankings": [
        {
            "list": "bookmark-managers",
            "name": "Bookmark managers",
            "page": "https://listme.name/best/bookmark-managers",
            "of": 10,
            "results": [
                {
                    "product": "karakeep",
                    "rank": 2,
                    "score": 90,
                    "verdict": "An open-source AGPL-3.0 app that saves links, notes and images with AI tagging, OCR and apps for iOS and Android. Self-hosting is free, and the Pro cloud plan costs $4 per month.",
                    "best_for": "Self-hosted saving with AI tags and full-page archives",
                    "spec": {
                        "platforms": "Web, iOS, Android, Chrome, Firefox",
                        "self_hosted": true,
                        "open_source": true,
                        "cost": "Free to self-host, Pro $4 per month"
                    }
                },
                {
                    "product": "shaarli",
                    "rank": 9,
                    "score": 76,
                    "verdict": "A minimal self-hosted link list that stores data in files without a database, under the zlib/libpng license. It has the smallest feature set here and needs a web server to run.",
                    "best_for": "File-based, self-hosted link sharing",
                    "spec": {
                        "platforms": "Web, self-hosted",
                        "self_hosted": true,
                        "open_source": true,
                        "cost": "Free to self-host"
                    }
                }
            ]
        }
    ],
    "ranks_higher_in_closest_shared_list": "karakeep",
    "page": "https://listme.name/compare/karakeep-vs-shaarli",
    "json": "https://listme.name/api/v1/compare/karakeep-vs-shaarli.json",
    "notes": [
        "Scores are editorial and only comparable inside one list. Products with connected_to_publisher true receive a disclosed ranking lift: https://listme.name/methodology"
    ],
    "source": "https://listme.name",
    "license": "Free to read and cite with attribution to listme.name.",
    "docs": "https://listme.name/developers"
}