Comparison · AI and machine learning books

An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition) vs Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction: which is better in 2026?

Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction ranks higher in our list of AI and machine learning books (#2 against #4, score 92.5 against 90.0), but the gap is small and the better choice depends on what you need.

  • 90.0
    Editorial score
    92.5
  • 2
    Formats
    2
  • Yes
    Free to use
    Yes

Which should you choose?

Choose An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition) if you want

Statistical learning for beginners with Python.

The most approachable text here, with Python labs and a free PDF. It stops short of the mathematics in the Murphy and Bishop books, which suits readers starting out.

Choose Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction if you want

Probabilistic modeling and Bayesian methods.

A broad, current treatment of machine learning as probabilistic modeling, with a free draft PDF. It is more mathematical than the practical texts here and newer than Bishop's 2006 book.

Side by side

An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition)Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction
Score90.092.5
Rank in list#4 of 10#2 of 10
PriceFreeFree PDF download; printed copies sold separatelyFreeFree draft PDF; hardcopy sold by MIT Press
Free to useYesYes
FormatsPDF, PrintPDF, Print
AuthorGareth James, Daniela Witten, Trevor Hastie, Robert Tibshirani and Jonathan TaylorKevin P. Murphy
LevelBeginnerAdvanced
Free to read onlineYesYes
Latest edition2023, Python edition2022, MIT Press; draft PDF updated
Math requiredLight: basic statisticsHeavy: probability and calculus
Best forStatistical learning for beginners with PythonProbabilistic modeling and Bayesian methods
Strengths
  • Free PDF of the full text
  • Python labs at the end of each chapter
  • Written by five statisticians from three universities
  • Free draft PDF and reproducible figure code
  • One probabilistic framework for many models
  • Published in 2022, after the author's 2012 text
Limits
  • Less mathematical depth than graduate texts
  • The labs assume some Python skill
  • Long and mathematical for self-study
  • Free draft carries a non-commercial, no-derivatives license
LinksVisit site Visit site

Questions about An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition) vs Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction

Is Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction better than An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition)?
Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction ranks higher in our list of AI and machine learning books (#2 against #4, score 92.5 against 90.0), but the gap is small and the better choice depends on what you need. An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition) is best for: statistical learning for beginners with Python. Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction is best for: probabilistic modeling and Bayesian methods.
Which is cheaper, An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition) or Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction?
An Introduction to Statistical Learning (Python edition): Free PDF download; printed copies sold separately. Probabilistic Machine Learning: An Introduction: Free draft PDF; hardcopy sold by MIT Press.